Last night the Angels lost to the Mariners 10-7. Normally this would not be a big deal, nor would it interest me for more than a second while passing a glance at baseball scores, but after further review I noticed that the Halos’ closer Francisco Rodriguez had blown a save. Still not earth-shattering news, but he happens to be the league leader and is on pace to smash the single-season record of 57 set by Bobby Thigpen of the White Sox in 1990.

Save my saves record!
Rodriguez, or “F-Rod” as he is known by those compelled to tag players with insipid nicknames based on abbreviations, has 46 saves so far. He gave up 3 runs on 3 hits and a walk in only a third of an inning against Seattle, so #47 will have to come some other time. This got me thinking about saves and how many great closers there have been over the years. Trying to put this record in perspective also led me to wonder who had the best season as a closer ever. Is it soley based on the number of saves? Lowest ERA? Team wins and postseason success? It’s hard to say, but just like home runs, it’s the number that goes in the books, not the story behind it. So with due respect to Bobby Thigpen and Francisco Rodriguez, dare I suggest that I have found the two best recorded seasons by a closer, and neither one of our subjects are included. First, though, let’s compare Thigpen and Rodriguez. Thigpen was 26 years old when he had his magical season. He was 4-6 in 77 games, pitched 88.7 innings, gave up 18 earned runs, walked 32, struck out 70 and had a 1.83 ERA. 1990 was the last year for old Comiskey Park, and the White Sox won 94 games but missed the playoffs by finishing 9 games back of the Oakland A’s in the old AL West. Thigpen did his part, imagine how many games back they would have finished without someone shutting the door in that many close games. The White Sox were not a juggernaut in 1990. Thigpen was a major factor in their success. Rodriguez, on the other hand, plays on what is easily the best team in the majors this year. With or without him, they are way ahead of the pack. I don’t want to sound like I am diminishing what he has accomplished, I’m not. But they have not relied on him to ‘bail them out’ to get where they are. Regardless, he is impressive and very important to the Angels and their chances in the postseason. Like Thigpen was then, he is also 26 years old in his best season to date. He is 2-2 in 56 games, has 50.1 innings pitched, has given up 16 earned runs, walked 29, struck out 55 and sports a 2.86 ERA. A strong finish will give him results very similar to Thigpen’s, But he should end up with more saves and a good shot at a World Series run. Sidenotes for these two pitchers: Rodriguez wears #57 of all numbers…Thigpen only saved 54 more games the rest of his career and was out of the league at the age of 30. Now, back to the two best overall seasons by a closer I mentioned earlier. I don’t know how to justify my decision, so just humor me and consider my choices as strictly my opinion. the second best season by a closer was in 2006 by Jonathan Papelbon of the Red Sox. At age 25 in his first season as “The Man”, Paps

Sit down
put together a lights out campaign that will be hard for him to ever top. The numbers: 4-2 in 59 games, 68.1 innings, 40 hits, 35 saves, 7 earned runs, 13 walks, 75 strikeouts and a 0.92 ERA. The facts: Dominated the league and showed no fear of any hitter he faced. This is how he started his career! He only pitched 17 innings in 2005, so this was a rookie punching out the best hitters in the AL night after night for the whole season. No slumps, no bumps, just dominance. He had more saves in 2007 and will again in 2008, but he will be hard pressed to be “on” for an entire summer like 2006. As for the best season ever by a closer, I had no doubt who it would be, just which season? Once Dennis Eckersley went to the bullpen

Drive Safely Folks
and transformed himself with the A’s, he was the poster boy for what you want from a closer for an extended period of time. Numbers don’t do him justice, but he had ‘em. The season that I think stands alone is 1990. Ironically, Oakland was the reason Thigpen was shut out of the playoffs and didn’t win the Cy-Young Award. The A’s were in the middle of another ”Swinging A’s”-like run, headed to their third straight World Series behind the “Bash Brothers” and Cy-Young winner Bob Welch. But it was Eck who really defined this team. He truly was “Game Over”. The numbers: 4-2 in 63 games, 73.1 innings, 41 hits, 48 saves, 5 earned runs, 4 walks, 73 strikeouts and a 0.61 ERA. The facts: Less baserunners allowed than saves recorded? Are you kidding me? 5 earned runs? is that a typo? And most important to a manager, 4 walks issued all year. 4. You did not see first base against Eck. I don’t care what anyone says to refute it, this is the best you could ever hope for out of your closer. There have been many great closers, but I’ll take Eck in 1990 as the best. Apologies for not mentioning Eric Gagne and John Smoltz who each had 55 saves in a season, and were very impressive in doing so, but they just don’t compare overall.